Academy
  • Log in
  • Sign up
  • StockWatch
  • Lobby
  • Academy
  • Investing
    • Planning Your Investments Setting investment goals
    • 8 Steps to Financial Freedom
    • How to Get Out of Debt
    • Dollar Cost Averaging with Example Calculations
    • Which Credit Card Should I Get?
    • Can I Retire on 1 Million Dollars? Is it Enough?
    • Investment Vehicles Best way to invest your money?
    • How to Budget Your Money
    • Choosing a Finance Advisor
    • Asset Classes: Shares, property, fixed interest
    • The Magic of Compound Interest
  • Shares
    • Stock Market Investing and Share Market Tips
    • Short Selling Explained: What is Short Selling
    • How to Trade Like a Professional Trader
    • What are E Minis Futures? How do I Trade Them?
    • Diversification Learn how to diversify your portfolio
    • What Is Ethical Investing?
    • Creating a Trading Plan
    • The S&P/ASX 200 Index (XJO)
    • Choosing A Broker
    • Guard Your Portfolio With Defensive Stocks
    • How Much Do I Need To Invest In Shares
    • Investing VS Trading
    • What does ex dividend mean? How to ensure you receive your dividends
    • If I Could Only Invest In One Thing...
    • What Are Shares Dividends?
    • Dividend Imputation System & Franking Credits Explained Calculations
    • What is the 'Market'?
    • What Shares Should I Buy?
    • How to Buy Shares, placing an order
    • Building a Investment Portfolio Strategy
    • Trading the ASX 200 Index: ETFs, CFDs, Futures and Options
    • Creating a Trading System
    • Understanding the Share Language & Jargon of the Share Market
    • What are Income Stocks? Best Income Stocks for 2010
    • How To Pick Growth Stocks?
    • Wesfarmers (WES) vs Woolworths (WOW)
    • David Jones (DJS) VS Myer (MYR)
    • Benefits of Investing in Shares
    • How to Make Money In Shares
    • How to Treat Trading Like a Business
    • BHP vs RIO
    • Making Money In a Bear Market
    • Investing in Cloud Computing Stocks
    • High Dividend Stocks
    • Make Money Trading the Share Market
    • ANZ vs CBA vs NAB vs WBC
  • Funds
    • Managed Funds Choosing the best fund for you
    • S&P/ASX 200 ETFs: STW, IOZ, VAS
    • Managed Funds or Direct Shares
    • ETFs (Exchange Traded Funds)
    • Introduction to Index Funds
    • ETF Trading
  • Fundamental Analysis
    • Fundamental Analysis of Stocks: Qualitative Factors of the Company
    • Fundamental Analysis of Stocks: Qualitative Factors of the Industry
    • Fundamental Analysis: Quantitative Factors, Book and Price to Book Ratio
    • Fundamental Analysis: Quantitative Factors, Earnings Per Share (EPS)
    • Fundamental Analysis: Quantitative Factors, Price to Earning (P/E) and PEG
    • Fundamental Analysis: Quantitative Factors, Short Interest
    • Warren Buffett: A genius investor, a philanthropist, and a role model for citizens
    • Benjamin Graham: Father of value investing
    • Phillip Fisher
    • Peter Lynch
  • Technical Analysis
    • Charting
      • Technical Analysis: Charting: Line Chart
      • Technical Analysis: Charting: Bar Chart
      • Technical Analysis: How to Read a Candlestick Chart
      • Technical Analysis: How to Read Point and Figure Charts
      • Technical Analysis: How to Draw Trend Lines On A Stock Chart
      • Technical Analysis: What are Stock Gaps & How to Trade Them
      • Technical Analysis: How to Read & Trade Chart Patterns
    • Technical Analysis: The Secret of Moving Averages Explained
    • Learn How To Trade Support and Resistance Levels
    • Technical Analysis Indicators: Leading versus Lagging Indicators
    • Trend Following Indicators Part 1: What Is a Trend?
    • Trend Following Indicators Part 2: Trading The Average Directional Index (ADX)
    • Trend Following Indicators Part 3: The Directional Movement Index (DMI)
    • MACD Indicator Explained
    • Technical Analysis Momentum Indicators: ROC, Stochastic & RSI
    • The Relative Strength Index RSI Indicator Explained
    • Stochastic Indicator Explained
    • Momentum Following Indicators: The TRIX Indicator
    • Volume Following Indicators In Technical Analysis
    • Volume Indicators: On Balanced Volume (OBV) Indicator
    • Volume Indicators: Money Flow Index (MFI) Indicator Explained
    • Volume Following Indicators: Percentage Volume Oscillator (PVO) Indicator
    • Technical Analysis: Parabolic Stop and Reversal (PSAR) Indicator
    • Technical Analysis: Stop Loss & Trailing Stop Loss Orders
  • Commodities
    • Should I Invest in Gold? Pros and Cons of Precious Metal Investing
    • Should I Buy Gold Now?
    • Investing In Silver 7 Methods to Gain Exposure to Silver
  • Day Trading
    • Common Day Trading Myths and Lies Debunked
    • Day Trading Rules Part 1: Setup Long
    • Day Trading Rules Part 2: Setup Short
    • Buying and Selling With the Trend
    • Day Trading: The Art of Controlling Your Emotions Part 1
    • Day Trading: The Art of Controlling Your Emotions Part 2
    • Intermediate Setups and Creating a Bias Part 1
    • Intermediate Setups and Creating a Bias Part 2
    • The Art of Channel Trading
    • Day Trading Example: Walking Through a Trade – Part 1
    • Day Trading Example: Walking Through a Trade – Part 2
    • Can I Make Money Day Trading? How to Become a Day Trader?
    • Tracking the Market and Day Trading Your Stock
    • High Frequency Trading
    • What is a Trading Robot? Should I Use One to Trade?
  • Forex
    • How to Trade FOREX – Beginners Guide
    • Trading Forex
  • Derivatives
    • Options
      • Options Trading: Call Options Explained
      • Options Trading: Put Options Explained
      • Options Trading: Why Trade Options?
      • Components of an Option
      • Understanding Option Pricing Fundamentals
      • Options Trading Examples
      • Options Trading Strategies
      • Options Trading Risks
      • The Covered Call Strategy
      • Trading Options Seminars: What You Will Learn in a Teaser Seminar
    • CFDs
      • What are CFD's? Why Trade them?
      • CFD Types: Direct Market Access (DMA) VS Market Maker (MM) The Pros & Cons
      • CFD Margin Requirements Initial and Variation Margin.
      • CFD Trading: Calculating Overnight Interest Payments (Financing fees) with example
      • CFD Trading: CFD real life examples with calculations (Long & short)
      • The Pros & Cons of Trading CFDs
      • CFD Trading Risks: Learn the risks associated with trading CFDs
      • How to Choose the Best CFD Provider for You
      • CFD Trading Top 5 Trading Mistakes
      • CFD Tax Treatment
      • Learn How To Trade CFDs: Developing a system that should make us money
      • CFD Trading Example Flight Centre (FLT)

CFD Types: Direct Market Access (DMA) VS Market Maker (MM) - The Pros & Cons

  1. Articles
  2. Derivatives
  3. CFDs
  4. CFD Type
20 July 2010
ยท
4 min read

Series 10 articles

  • What are CFD's? Why Trade them?
  • CFD Types: Direct Market Access (DMA) VS Market Maker (MM) - The Pros & Cons
  • CFD Margin Requirements - Initial and Variation Margin.
  • CFD Trading: Calculating Overnight Interest Payments (Financing fees) with example
  • CFD Trading: CFD real life examples with calculations (Long & short)
  • The Pros & Cons of Trading CFDs
  • CFD Trading Risks: Learn the risks associated with trading CFDs
  • How to Choose the Best CFD Provider for You
  • CFD Trading - Top 5 Trading Mistakes
  • CFD Tax Treatment

Two major types of CFD models exist. One is called Direct Market Access (DMA), and the other is termed Market Maker (MM). They each have their own advantageous and disadvantageous. But before we discuss the pros and cons, what do the two models DMA and MM really mean?

Direct Market Access

Contracts For Difference can be traded by the Direct Market Access method. This means that the CFD order is placed in an order book with buyers and sellers trying to get the prices at the bid and ask. Buying and selling a CFD in this manner will influence the share price of the underlying asset. The CFD price will be directly related to the current market price and will be influenced by asset liquidity.

Direct Market Access allows for complete transparency of transaction with no middle man adjusting prices – just you and the open market.

Market Maker

Trading through a middle man, or a Market Maker, is another option available. His pricing, while claiming to mirror market prices, will often be slightly less competitive to allow for the Market Makers profit. Transaction times might also be slower from adding another leg onto the transaction.

Essentially, he takes the real market and then using it as a baseline, creates his own. He is not really trading with the market but has created his own synthetic market.

Pros and Cons

Each method has its own unique advantageous and disadvantageous ranging from competitive price and transparency, to the amount of choice.

 Direct Market Access on ASX CFD’sMarket Maker on OTC CFD’s
Transparency and PricingThe DMA model has complete transparency whereby the purchaser of the CFD can determine his exact entry and exit values.Having a middle man to execute your orders will create a degree of separation. He has the ability to set his own prices and market, although they are still somewhat based on market prices.
StructureBased exactly on market values.Mirroring closely to market values.
Market LiquidityBased on the market.Can sometimes provide better than the market.
Influence on share prices?Trading DMA CFD’s will make the share price go up or down.Trading MM CFD’s will not affect the current market share price of the asset.
Profits Made by Portal?Because this position is 100% hedged, the Direct Market Access makes money from the transaction fees only.The Market Maker does not need to completely hedge his position. This means he may profit as a direct result of your loss or your profit.
Speed of TransactionQuick and DirectSomewhat slower due to price being re-quoted and at discretion of dealer
Markets Offered?Usually limited to the top 50 stocks on the ASX plus a few other limited offerings.Ability to offer international investments and currency pairs

This may appear like a complete slam-dunk against the Market Maker model. But under certain circumstances an individual may choose to trade with the MM system. Let’s examine this a little further.

DMA vs MM?

Most people trading the top stocks on the ASX will choose to use the Direct Access Model. They will receive a more competitive price, quicker transactions, and less manipulation. A trader using the DMA needs to only worry about his strategy and timing, without suspicion of the big bad wolf trying to undermine his every trade.

However, certain traders will choose to use the Market Maker for another reason. Perhaps they want to trade not only the more commonly offered securities but some of the more exotic ones as well. Maybe they also want to speculate on International exchanges, spot prices on precious metals, currencies, energies, interest rates, and bonds.

While the ASX CFD’s may provide limited options with these, the Market Maker may provide a wider array of options. Also, in theory the MM may be able to provide a lower initial transaction fee since he is dealing with a synthetic market and not placing orders in the ASX trade book. This is in theory only, since there are many other ways to pad the transaction.

As well, liquidity with the DMA model is directly related to market liquidity. When dealing with a very illiquid asset, acquiring CFD’s might prove to be costly and difficult. The Market Maker does not need to physically purchase the asset, which works around the liquidity problem. You can take up a very large position with an ‘over the counter’ CFD on an illiquid stock without affecting the price any.

Keep in mind that this article is comparing ASX CFD’s as the DMA model, and OTC (Over The Counter) CFD’s being the tool for Market Makers. If a trader wants the best of both worlds, he has the option to use Direct Market Access with Over the Counter CFD’s, which transactions are sometimes dubbed Straight Through Processing (STP) or ‘over the counter’ DMA as opposed to MM.

Final Word on Direct Market Access and Market Makers

Whether a trader wishes expose himself to the potential risk and reward of a Market Maker is up to him. But clearly understanding the pros and cons of each method will at least make him aware the associated risks with Market Makers, and whether the advantages in his particular case outweigh the negatives.

For most new CFD traders, they will likely choose to trade ASX CFD’s, or ‘over the counter’ CFD’s where the order is placed in a trade book and not through a Market Maker.

Series: Previous | Next
derivatives cfds forex gold silver
You May Also Like
  • Learn How To Trade CFDs: Developing a system that should make us money
  • ETFs (Exchange Traded Funds)
About Privacy Contact v2.0.1
© 2025 The Domain Publisher Pty Ltd.
This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn more about cookies